Skip to content

Bank Trading Activities Deep Dive Guide

Version: 1.0 Last Updated: 2026-01-28 Focus: Schedule HC-D (Trading) and Schedule HC-L (Derivatives) Analysis


Table of Contents

  1. Introduction to Bank Trading Activities
  2. Schedule HC-D: Trading Assets & Liabilities
  3. Schedule HC-L: Derivatives and Off-Balance Sheet
  4. The HC → HC-D → HC-L Linkage
  5. Call Report Equivalents (RC-D, RC-L)
  6. FR Y-14 Trading Schedules
  7. Pillar 3 Market Risk Templates
  8. Reconciliation Checks
  9. Major Trading BHCs
  10. Appendix: Complete Code Tables

1. Introduction to Bank Trading Activities

1.1 What is Bank Trading?

Bank trading activities involve positions held for: - Market making: Providing liquidity to clients - Proprietary trading: Taking positions for profit (limited post-Volcker) - Hedging: Managing risk from other banking activities - Customer facilitation: Supporting client transactions

1.2 Regulatory Framework

Trading activities are governed by multiple regulatory frameworks:

Regulation Focus Key Requirements
Volcker Rule Proprietary trading Restricts prop trading, requires compliance
Basel III Capital Market risk capital for trading book
Dodd-Frank Derivatives Central clearing, margin requirements
SEC/CFTC Derivatives Swap dealer registration, reporting

1.3 Key Regulatory Filings for Trading

Form Schedule Content
FR Y-9C HC-D Trading assets and liabilities
FR Y-9C HC-L Derivatives notional and fair value
FR Y-9C HC-Q Fair value hierarchy
FR Y-14Q Schedule G Trading revenue, VaR
Pillar 3 MR1-MR4 Market risk disclosures

1.4 Why Trading Data Matters

Understanding bank trading data is essential for:

  1. Risk Assessment: Evaluating market risk exposure
  2. Capital Analysis: Understanding trading book capital requirements
  3. Revenue Analysis: Decomposing bank earnings
  4. Systemic Risk: Assessing interconnectedness via derivatives
  5. Volcker Compliance: Monitoring permitted activities

2. Schedule HC-D: Trading Assets & Liabilities

2.1 Overview

Schedule HC-D provides the detailed breakdown of trading book positions summarized on the main balance sheet (Schedule HC Items 5 and 15).

Schedule HC (Balance Sheet)
├── Item 5: Trading Assets → Detailed in HC-D Items 1-12
└── Item 15: Trading Liabilities → Detailed in HC-D Items 13-15

2.2 Trading Assets Breakdown

Securities Held for Trading (Items 1-5)

Item 1: U.S. Treasury Securities
MDRM Period Scope
BHCM3531 2018-03-31 to present Domestic + Foreign consolidated
BHCK3531 1995-03-31 to 2018-03-31 Domestic only (legacy)

Content: U.S. Treasury bills, notes, bonds, TIPS held in trading book.

Use: Primary safe-haven trading asset; large positions at major dealers.

Item 2: U.S. Government Agency Obligations
MDRM Period Scope
BHCM3532 2018-03-31 to present Domestic + Foreign consolidated
BHCK3532 1995-03-31 to 2018-03-31 Domestic only (legacy)

Content: FNMA, FHLMC, FHLB, GNMA debt securities (non-MBS).

Item 3: Municipal Securities
MDRM Period Scope
BHCM3533 2018-03-31 to present Domestic + Foreign consolidated
BHCK3533 1995-03-31 to 2018-03-31 Domestic only (legacy)

Content: Securities issued by states and political subdivisions.

Item 4: Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS)

The MBS section underwent major restructuring in 2011:

Current Structure (2011-present):

Line Description MDRM Start
4.a.(1) Residential MBS - GNMA pass-through BHCKK197 2011-03-31
4.a.(2) Residential MBS - FNMA/FHLMC pass-through BHCKK198 2011-03-31
4.b All other residential MBS BHCKK199 2011-03-31
4.c.(1) Commercial MBS - agency issued BHCKK200 2011-03-31
4.c.(2) Commercial MBS - all other BHCKK201 2011-03-31

Legacy Structure (pre-2011):

Line Description MDRM End
4 MBS pass-through (combined) BHCK3534 2009-03-31
4 All other MBS (combined) BHCK3536 2009-03-31

Key Distinction: - Agency MBS (K197, K198, K200): Government-backed, lower risk - Non-Agency MBS (K199, K201): Private-label, higher risk, focus during 2008 crisis

Item 5: Other Debt Securities

Current Structure (2018-present):

Line Description MDRM Start
5.a Structured financial products BHCKHT62 2018-06-30
5.b Other debt securities (incl ABS) BHCKK202 2011-03-31

Content: - 5.a: CDOs, CLOs, structured notes, complex products - 5.b: Corporate bonds, ABS, foreign government debt, other

Loans Held for Trading (Item 6)

Current Structure (2018-present):

Line Description MDRM Start
6.a 1-4 family residential loans BHCKHT63 2018-06-30
6.b Other real estate loans BHCKHT64 2018-06-30
6.c Commercial and industrial loans BHCKF614 2008-03-31
6.d Consumer loans BHCKHT65 2018-06-30
6.e Other loans BHCKF618 2008-03-31

Use Cases: - Mortgage trading desks (Items 6.a, 6.b) - Leveraged loan trading (Item 6.c) - Consumer loan securitization flow (Item 6.d)

Other Trading Assets (Item 9)

MDRM Period Scope
BHCM3541 2018-03-31 to present Domestic + Foreign
BHCK3541 1995-03-31 to 2018-03-31 Domestic only (legacy)

Content: Residual trading assets not elsewhere classified: - Equity securities held for trading - Precious metals - Physical commodities - Other

Derivatives with Positive Fair Value (Item 11)

MDRM Period
BHCT3543 2009-06-30 to present
BHCK3543 1995-03-31 to 2018-03-31 (legacy)

Critical Linkage: This item links to Schedule HC-L fair values.

Formula:

BHCT3543 = Sum of all positive fair value derivatives from HC-L
         = Trading positive FV + Non-trading hedge positive FV
         = (BHCK8733 + BHCK8734 + BHCK8735 + BHCK8736)
         + (BHCK8741 + BHCK8742 + BHCK8743 + BHCK8744)

Total Trading Assets (Item 12)

MDRM Period
BHCT3545 1995-12-31 to present

Reconciliation Rule:

HC-D Item 12 (BHCT3545) = Schedule HC Item 5 (BHCT3545)

2.3 Trading Liabilities Breakdown

Short Positions (Item 13)

Short positions were added post-crisis (2009) to increase transparency:

Line Description MDRM Start
13.a.(1) Short positions - Equity securities BHCKG209 2009-03-31
13.a.(2) Short positions - Debt securities BHCKG210 2009-03-31
13.a.(3) Short positions - All other BHCKG211 2009-03-31
13.b Other trading liabilities BHCKF624 2008-03-31

Content: - Securities sold short pending delivery - Obligations to return borrowed securities - Other trading book liabilities

Derivatives with Negative Fair Value (Item 14)

MDRM Period
BHCT3547 2009-06-30 to present
BHCK3547 1994-03-31 to present (legacy)

Formula:

BHCT3547 = Sum of all negative fair value derivatives from HC-L
         = Trading negative FV + Non-trading hedge negative FV
         = (BHCK8737 + BHCK8738 + BHCK8739 + BHCK8740)
         + (BHCK8745 + BHCK8746 + BHCK8747 + BHCK8748)

Total Trading Liabilities (Item 15)

MDRM Period
BHCT3548 1989-09-30 to present

Reconciliation Rule:

HC-D Item 15 (BHCT3548) = Schedule HC Item 15 (BHCT3548)

2.4 Historical Evolution of HC-D

Period Change Impact
1995 Initial structure Basic trading asset/liability reporting
2008 Post-crisis expansion Added loan detail, other trading liab
2009 Short positions added Items 13.a added for short sales
2011 MBS granular breakout K197-K202 codes added
2018 Further granularity HT62-HT65 codes; prefix split

3. Schedule HC-L: Derivatives and Off-Balance Sheet

3.1 Overview

Schedule HC-L reports derivatives in two dimensions: 1. Notional amounts: Contract face value by product type 2. Fair values: Mark-to-market value by asset class

3.2 Understanding Notional vs Fair Value

Measure Definition Use
Notional Face/principal amount of contract Activity level, exposure
Fair Value Current mark-to-market value Balance sheet impact

Example: A $100M interest rate swap at inception: - Notional: $100M - Fair Value: $0 (at-the-money at inception)

After rates move, same swap might have: - Notional: $100M (unchanged) - Fair Value: +$2M (in-the-money) or -$3M (out-of-the-money)

Key Insight: Notional >> Fair Value typically

For G-SIBs, notional amounts can exceed $50 trillion while fair values are in the hundreds of billions.

3.3 Notional Amounts by Product Type

Futures (Exchange-Traded)

Asset Class MDRM Notes
Interest Rate BHCK8693 Treasury futures, Eurodollar futures
Foreign Exchange BHCK8694 Currency futures
Equity BHCK8695 Index futures, single stock futures
Commodity/Other BHCK8696 Oil, gold, agricultural futures

Characteristics: - Standardized contracts - Exchange clearing (CCPs) - Daily mark-to-market - Lower counterparty risk

Forwards (OTC)

Asset Class MDRM Notes
Interest Rate BHCK8697 FRAs
Foreign Exchange BHCK8698 FX forwards, spots > 2 days
Equity BHCK8699 Equity forwards
Commodity/Other BHCK8700 Commodity forwards

Characteristics: - Customized contracts - Bilateral counterparty risk - Settlement at maturity

Note: FX forwards (BHCK8698) include spot transactions with settlement > 2 business days.

Swaps

Asset Class MDRM Notes
Interest Rate BHCK3450 LARGEST category; fixed-for-floating
Cross-Currency BHCK3826 Currency swaps
Equity BHCK8719 Total return swaps on equity
Commodity/Other BHCK8720 Commodity swaps

Interest Rate Swaps (BHCK3450): - Largest derivatives category by notional - JPMorgan alone: >$40 trillion notional - Used for ALM hedging, trading, client facilitation

Options

Options are reported separately by: - Venue: Exchange vs OTC - Direction: Written (sold) vs Purchased (bought) - Asset Class: IR, FX, Equity, Commodity

Asset Class Exch Written Exch Purch OTC Written OTC Purch
Interest Rate BHCK8701 BHCK8705 BHCK8709 BHCK8713
Foreign Exchange BHCK8702 BHCK8706 BHCK8710 BHCK8714
Equity BHCK8703 BHCK8707 BHCK8711 BHCK8715
Commodity/Other BHCK8704 BHCK8708 BHCK8712 BHCK8716

Written vs Purchased: - Written (Sold): Bank receives premium, has obligation - Purchased (Bought): Bank pays premium, has right

Credit Derivatives

Credit derivatives were added in 2006 (Q1 2006):

Type Protection Sold (Guarantor) Protection Bought (Beneficiary)
Credit Default Swaps BHCKC968 BHCKC969
Total Return Swaps BHCKC970 BHCKC971
Other Credit Deriv BHCKC974 BHCKC975

Credit Default Swaps (CDS): - Protection Sold (C968): Bank is guarantor, assumes credit risk - Protection Bought (C969): Bank is beneficiary, hedges credit risk

Net CDS Position:

Net CDS Exposure = Protection Bought - Protection Sold
                 = BHCKC969 - BHCKC968
- Positive: Net buyer of protection (hedged/bearish) - Negative: Net seller of protection (risk-taking/bullish)

3.4 Fair Values by Asset Class

Trading Derivatives

Asset Class Positive FV Negative FV
Interest Rate BHCK8733 BHCK8737
Foreign Exchange BHCK8734 BHCK8738
Equity BHCK8735 BHCK8739
Commodity/Other BHCK8736 BHCK8740

Positive Fair Value: Derivatives that are in-the-money (assets) Negative Fair Value: Derivatives that are out-of-the-money (liabilities)

Non-Trading Hedges

Asset Class Positive FV Negative FV
Interest Rate BHCK8741 BHCK8745
Foreign Exchange BHCK8742 BHCK8746
Equity BHCK8743 BHCK8747
Commodity/Other BHCK8744 BHCK8748

Trading vs Non-Trading: - Trading: Held for market making, customer facilitation, (limited) prop trading - Non-Trading Hedges: Designated hedges of banking book items (loans, deposits)

3.5 Netting and Gross vs Net Fair Value

Reported fair values are gross (before netting).

Netting: Under ISDA master agreements and CSAs, banks can net: - Positive and negative fair values with same counterparty - Collateral received/posted

Balance Sheet Impact:

Gross Positive FV (HC-L) ≥ Net Derivative Assets (Balance Sheet)

Banks apply netting for balance sheet presentation but report gross in HC-L.


4. The HC → HC-D → HC-L Linkage

4.1 Hierarchical Structure

Schedule HC (Balance Sheet)
│
├── Item 5: Trading Assets (BHCT3545)
│   │
│   └── Schedule HC-D (Trading Detail)
│       ├── Items 1-5: Securities
│       ├── Item 6: Loans
│       ├── Item 9: Other trading assets
│       ├── Item 11: Derivatives positive FV ─────────┐
│       └── Item 12: TOTAL (= HC Item 5)              │
│                                                      │
├── Item 15: Trading Liabilities (BHCT3548)           │
│   │                                                  │
│   └── Schedule HC-D (Trading Detail)                │
│       ├── Item 13: Short positions & other          │
│       ├── Item 14: Derivatives negative FV ─────────┤
│       └── Item 15: TOTAL (= HC Item 15)             │
│                                                      │
└───────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │
                                                    │ │
Schedule HC-L (Derivatives Detail) ◄────────────────┴─┘
├── Notional Amounts (by product type)
│   ├── Futures
│   ├── Forwards
│   ├── Swaps
│   ├── Options
│   └── Credit Derivatives
│
└── Fair Values (by asset class)
    ├── Trading Positive FV ──► Sums to HC-D Item 11
    ├── Trading Negative FV ──► Sums to HC-D Item 14
    ├── Non-Trading Positive FV ──► Sums to HC-D Item 11
    └── Non-Trading Negative FV ──► Sums to HC-D Item 14

4.2 Key Reconciliation Formulas

Trading Assets Derivatives

HC-D Item 11 (BHCT3543) = HC-L Trading Pos FV + HC-L Non-Trading Pos FV

Where:
  HC-L Trading Pos FV = BHCK8733 + BHCK8734 + BHCK8735 + BHCK8736
  HC-L Non-Trading Pos FV = BHCK8741 + BHCK8742 + BHCK8743 + BHCK8744

Trading Liabilities Derivatives

HC-D Item 14 (BHCT3547) = HC-L Trading Neg FV + HC-L Non-Trading Neg FV

Where:
  HC-L Trading Neg FV = BHCK8737 + BHCK8738 + BHCK8739 + BHCK8740
  HC-L Non-Trading Neg FV = BHCK8745 + BHCK8746 + BHCK8747 + BHCK8748

4.3 Notional to Fair Value Relationship

Important: Notional amounts do NOT link directly to balance sheet.

The relationship between notional and fair value: - Notional represents contract size (activity level) - Fair value represents economic value (balance sheet) - Fair value is typically << 5% of notional - Fair value can be positive or negative

Example (Illustrative G-SIB):

Interest Rate Swaps:
  Notional: $40 trillion
  Positive FV: $200 billion (0.5% of notional)
  Negative FV: $195 billion
  Net FV: $5 billion


5. Call Report Equivalents (RC-D, RC-L)

5.1 Parallel Structure

Call Report schedules RC-D and RC-L mirror FR Y-9C schedules HC-D and HC-L.

FR Y-9C Call Report Level
HC-D RC-D BHC consolidated → Bank level
HC-L RC-L BHC consolidated → Bank level

5.2 MDRM Prefix Conversion

Y-9C Prefix Call Report Prefix
BHCK RCFD
BHCM RCFD (or RCON)
BHCT RCFD

Example: - Y-9C Total Trading Assets: BHCT3545 - Call Report Total Trading Assets: RCFD3545

5.3 Key Differences

Aspect FR Y-9C (HC-D/HC-L) Call Report (RC-D/RC-L)
Entity Level Consolidated BHC Individual bank
Includes All subsidiaries Bank only
Nonbank Trading Included Excluded
Foreign Offices Consolidated Depends on prefix

5.4 BHC vs Sum of Banks

Warning: BHC trading data ≠ Sum of subsidiary bank data

Reasons: 1. Nonbank trading: Broker-dealer subs trade but aren't banks 2. Eliminations: Intercompany positions eliminated at BHC level 3. Different reporting: Some items differ between forms


6. FR Y-14 Trading Schedules

6.1 Overview

FR Y-14 provides granular trading data not available in FR Y-9C.

Form Schedule Content Frequency
Y-14Q G.1 Trading Revenue Quarterly
Y-14Q G.2 VaR/Stressed VaR Quarterly
Y-14Q E.1 Top Counterparties Quarterly
Y-14Q E.2 CVA Quarterly

6.2 Schedule G.1: Trading Revenue

Breaks down trading revenue by: - Product type (IR, FX, Equity, Commodity, Credit) - Revenue component (Bid-ask, Position change, CVA)

Links to FR Y-9C: - Total trading revenue should reconcile to HI trading revenue items

6.3 Schedule G.2: VaR and Stressed VaR

Reports: - Daily VaR at 99% confidence - Stressed VaR (crisis period calibration) - VaR breaches/backtesting

Regulatory Use: Determines market risk capital under IMA

6.4 Schedule E.1: Top Counterparties

Reports: - Top 50 counterparties by exposure - Gross and net exposure - Collateral

Links to HC-L: Derivatives counterparty exposure detail

6.5 Schedule E.2: CVA

Reports: - Credit Valuation Adjustment by counterparty - CVA reserves - CVA capital


7. Pillar 3 Market Risk Templates

7.1 Overview

Basel III Pillar 3 requires public disclosure of market risk.

Template Content
MR1 Market risk under IMA
MR2 RWA flow statement
MR3 IMA VaR values
MR4 VaR comparison to P&L

7.2 MR1: Market Risk Under Internal Models Approach

Reports: - VaR-based capital - Stressed VaR capital - Incremental Risk Charge (IRC) - Comprehensive Risk Measure (CRM) - Total market risk capital

Links to FR Y-9C: Market risk capital in HC-R

7.3 MR3: IMA Values for Trading Portfolios

Reports daily VaR at 99%: - Maximum, minimum, average - Period-end value

Links to FR Y-14Q: Schedule G.2 VaR data

7.4 MR4: Comparison of VaR Estimates with Actual P&L

Backtesting disclosure: - VaR vs actual P&L chart - Number of exceptions - Model performance assessment


8. Reconciliation Checks

8.1 Balance Sheet to Schedule HC-D

Check Formula Must Equal
Trading Assets HC Item 5 = HC-D Item 12 Exact match
Trading Liabilities HC Item 15 = HC-D Item 15 Exact match

8.2 HC-D to HC-L (Derivatives)

Check Formula
Deriv Pos FV HC-D Item 11 = Sum(HC-L Trading Pos FV) + Sum(HC-L Non-Trading Pos FV)
Deriv Neg FV HC-D Item 14 = Sum(HC-L Trading Neg FV) + Sum(HC-L Non-Trading Neg FV)

Detailed:

BHCT3543 = (BHCK8733 + BHCK8734 + BHCK8735 + BHCK8736) +
           (BHCK8741 + BHCK8742 + BHCK8743 + BHCK8744)

BHCT3547 = (BHCK8737 + BHCK8738 + BHCK8739 + BHCK8740) +
           (BHCK8745 + BHCK8746 + BHCK8747 + BHCK8748)

8.3 HC-D Internal Sums

Check Formula
Trading Assets HC-D Item 12 = Items 1+2+3+4+5+6+9+11
Trading Liabilities HC-D Item 15 = Items 13+14

8.4 Common Discrepancies

Issue Cause Resolution
Small differences Rounding Accept if < $1M
Large differences Reporting error Flag for review
Missing data Threshold Bank may not report if below threshold
Historical breaks Code changes Check HISTORICAL_CODE_TRANSITIONS.csv

9. Major Trading BHCs

9.1 Overview of G-SIB Trading Activity

The largest trading operations are concentrated in a few G-SIBs:

BHC Trading Assets ($B) Derivatives Notional ($T) Primary Focus
JPMorgan Chase ~600 ~55 Universal
Goldman Sachs ~450 ~45 Investment bank
Morgan Stanley ~350 ~35 Investment bank
Bank of America ~250 ~40 Universal
Citigroup ~300 ~45 Universal
Wells Fargo ~50 ~10 Commercial bank

9.2 Trading Profile Differences

Investment Bank Focused (Goldman, Morgan Stanley)

  • Trading assets ~30-40% of total assets
  • Large equity and commodity trading
  • Prime brokerage
  • Lower deposit funding

Universal Bank (JPM, BAC, Citi)

  • Trading assets ~15-20% of total assets
  • Large interest rate derivatives (ALM)
  • Significant FX operations
  • Deposit-funded

Commercial Bank Focused (Wells Fargo)

  • Trading assets ~3-5% of total assets
  • Primarily interest rate hedging
  • Limited market-making
  • Deposit-funded

9.3 Key RSSD Identifiers

BHC RSSD ID Lead Bank RSSD
JPMorgan Chase & Co. 1039502 852218 (JPM Bank NA)
Goldman Sachs Group 2380443 2182786 (GS Bank USA)
Morgan Stanley 2162966 1456501 (MS Bank NA)
Bank of America Corp 1073757 480228 (Bank of America NA)
Citigroup Inc. 1951350 476810 (Citibank NA)
Wells Fargo & Co. 1120754 451965 (Wells Fargo Bank NA)

10. Appendix: Complete Code Tables

10.1 HC-D Complete Code Reference

See HC_D_TRADING_ASSETS.csv for complete listing.

10.2 HC-L Complete Code Reference

See HC_L_DERIVATIVES.csv for complete listing.

10.3 Cross-Reference Summary

Concept Y-9C MDRM Call MDRM HC-D Link HC-L Link
Total Trading Assets BHCT3545 RCFD3545 Item 12 -
Total Trading Liabilities BHCT3548 RCFD3548 Item 15 -
Derivatives Pos FV BHCT3543 RCFD3543 Item 11 Fair Value Section
Derivatives Neg FV BHCT3547 RCFD3547 Item 14 Fair Value Section
IR Swaps Notional BHCK3450 RCFD3450 - Notional Section
CDS Sold BHCKC968 RCFDC968 - Credit Deriv Section
CDS Bought BHCKC969 RCFDC969 - Credit Deriv Section

10.4 Data Quality Checklist

Before using trading data, verify:

  • [ ] Correct MDRM codes for time period
  • [ ] Prefix matches desired scope (domestic vs consolidated)
  • [ ] HC-D totals match HC balance sheet
  • [ ] HC-L fair values sum to HC-D derivatives
  • [ ] No unexpected zeros or missing values
  • [ ] Historical code transitions handled

Document Control

Version Date Author Changes
1.0 2026-01-28 N. Anderson Initial trading activities guide

End of Trading Activities Guide